James Heale

James Heale

James Heale is The Spectator’s deputy political editor.

Starmer pauses Chagos deal

Keir Starmer has tonight been forced to stall the Bill which would hand the Chagos Islands over to Mauritius. The legislation enabling the deal was expected to be debated in the Lords on Monday. But this evening, it was revealed that the votes have been delayed amid parliamentary ping-pong and a backlash from the Americans. Both the Conservatives and Reform UK are keen to take credit for the pause in the bill, under which Britain would give up the archipelago and lease back the Diego Garcia base. The Conservative case for credit is on the legislative front. Peers like Lord Hannan argue that the U-turn occurred only after the Tories had put out a rare three-line Whip for Monday, with ministers concluding that their Bill would fall.

Does British politics reward traitors or faithfuls?

From our UK edition

22 min listen

With the Conservatives on watch for further defectors, academic Richard Johnson and Conservative peer Danny Finkelstein join James Heale to discuss whether British politics rewards traitors or faithfuls. Richard points out that often personal success is dependent on whether the party goes on to be a major or minor player in British politics; Winston Churchill and Shaun Woodward fared better, while Shirley Williams and Mark Reckless had less success. Danny – whose political career began with the SDP in the 1980s – also takes us through his personal experience and the challenges of defecting, from ideology and demography to the perception of betrayal. How fundamental is the shift taking place in British politics? Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Andy Burnham is back in the game – and Robert Jenrick reveals all

From our UK edition

17 min listen

Three big stories for James Heale and Tim Shipman to pick over today: Andy Burnham’s return, the Donald Trump that refuses to go away, and the continued fallout of Robert Jenrick’s defection to Reform. This afternoon we found out that former Labour minister Andrew Gwynne is on the brink of standing down as an MP, after losing the whip during last year’s WhatsApp group scandal. A by-election is therefore on the cards in Gwynne’s Manchester seat, potentially paving the way for the ever-ambitious local mayor Andy Burnham to return to the Commons and make a leadership challenge against Keir Starmer. Would he be able to mobilise enough support?

Andy Burnham is back in the game – and Robert Jenrick reveals all

Badenoch pledges to MPs to keep right

From our UK edition

To committee room 14, where many of the remaining 117 Tory MPs crammed in tonight to hear from their leader. Kemi Badenoch was welcomed with 25 seconds of prolonged banging from her colleagues, after a week in which, first Robert Jenrick, and then Andrew Rosindell chose to defect to Reform. Having addressed both the right-wing 92 Group and Common Sense Group on Monday, Badenoch sought to build on that speech and put recent controversies to bed. She told assembled MPs that, with regards to Jenrick, 'We lost someone not on ideology, but personal ambition' before suggesting that the real question ought to be 'What are we winning for?

Starmer turns on Trump

Starmer turns on Trump

From our UK edition

10 min listen

Keir Starmer scored a rare win at PMQs, talking tough on Trump in light of the President’s escalating rhetoric on Greenland and the Chagos Islands. Kemi Badenoch pressed the Prime Minister on foreign affairs and Britain’s relationship with the US president, and Starmer departed from his usual caution to strike a notably firmer tone. What does this moment tell us about Labour’s emerging approach to Trump – and is the UK political class finally losing patience with the volatility of the White House? Was this the closest we’ll get to a Keir Starmer Love Actually Prime Minister moment? James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman and Isabel Hardman. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

The scandal of China’s ‘super embassy’

From our UK edition

13 min listen

China's controversial ‘super embassy’ has been approved, after years of debate over the security risks. Campaigners had called on ministers not to give the site the green light, given its proximity to important internet cables that support the City of London. MI5 have admitted they can't 'wholly eliminate' the national security risks around the site. Megan McElroy is joined by James Heale and Sophia Gaston, research fellow at King's College London, to discuss. There's more international chaos for Keir Starmer too – overnight, Donald Trump described plans to hand over the sovereignty of the Chagos islands as 'an act of great stupidity.' Where on earth does this leave the special relationship?

The scandal of China’s ‘super embassy’

Greenland: why Europe needs to ‘grow up’ | with Tim Marshall

From our UK edition

15 min listen

Donald Trump has thrown another diplomatic hand grenade. This weekend, the President threatened sweeping tariffs on countries backing Greenland’s independence – a move that has rattled European capitals and reignited questions about America’s global strategy. Is this about Arctic security, rare earth minerals, or something more personal? As tensions rise, how should Britain respond? Can diplomacy defuse Trump’s latest escalation, or does this mark a deeper shift in US–European relations – and the future of Nato itself? James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman and Tim Marshall, foreign affairs analyst and author of Prisoners of Geography. Produced by Megan McElroy and Oscar Edmondson.

Greenland: why Europe needs to 'grow up' | with Tim Marshall

Keir Starmer chooses jaw jaw over trade war with Trump

From our UK edition

There used to be a sign up in No. 10 which quoted Gilbert and Sullivan. ‘Quiet calm deliberation disentangles every knot,’ read the plaque, installed by Harold Macmillan. It is advice that Keir Starmer has taken to heart, as Donald Trump seemingly tries to tie Nato in as many twists and bows as possible. The Prime Minister had an unenviable task in his press conference this morning. He sought to both firmly resist Trump’s demands to annex Greenland – while desperately trying not to escalate the issue further. His approach might be summed up by another Macmillan quote: that ‘jaw, jaw is better than war war.’ At his presser, Starmer’s tone was grave, noting how the world has become ‘markedly more turbulent in recent weeks’.

Andrew Rosindell defects to Reform

From our UK edition

Reform UK has gained its seventh MP after Andrew Rosindell switched sides on Sunday night. The longtime Member for Romford was unveiled after a rapid series of talks earlier today. In a statement Nigel Farage said that ‘Andrew is a great patriot. The Tories’ lies and hypocrisy over the Chagos Islands betrayal has tipped him over the edge, and we are delighted to welcome him to our ranks.’ Rosindell is a longtime champion of the British Overseas Territories, an ardent Brexiteer and – at the time of his defection– a serving member of Priti Patel's shadow foreign affairs team. Two factors are understood to be responsible for his defection. The first is the aforementioned Chagos deal, the handling of which by the Tory front bench had come to increasingly exasperate Rosindell.

Debate: what’s the point of the Lib Dems?

From our UK edition

24 min listen

As Ed Davey condemned Donald Trump's military manoeuvres abroad, Annabel Denham looked on and asked 'what's the point of the Liberal Democrats?'. Thinking about the Lib Dem's longstanding europhile stance, the senior political correspondent at the Telegraph wrote: 'the party that once stood on a tradition of civil liberties now wants us to rejoin a bloc which regulates everything'. Calum Miller MP – foreign affairs spokesperson for the Liberal Democrats – joins Annabel and deputy political editor James Heale to address Annabel's challenge that the party is defined more by opposition the other parties than by their own policies. So, from localism and the UK's place in the world to free markets and social care, what do the Lib Dems stand for? And what constitutes 'liberalism' today?

Jenrick vs Badenoch: who won yesterday’s defection?

From our UK edition

10 min listen

Yesterday was a breathless day in Westminster. The defection of Robert Jenrick spawned plenty of headlines and even more memes. But now that the dust has settled, how has the news been received? Was it a total victory for Reform, and evidence that they are slowly swallowing up the Tory party, or is Kemi still in the race? Today, the assisted dying bill is back in the Lords. As discussions about this legislation drag on, does its implementation look increasingly unlikely? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Tim Shipman and James Heale. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Jenrick vs Badenoch: who won yesterday's defection?

Inside Jenrick & Reform’s shotgun marriage

From our UK edition

15 min listen

Robert Jenrick has sensationally defected to Reform. After a day that started with his sacking from the Conservatives – over plotting to reject – continued with the will-he-won’t-he drama of whether Farage would accept him as a new Reform member this afternoon; it ends with a press conference welcoming him to Farage’s gang. So what happens now? Kemi Badenoch was praised for her show of strength in swiftly expelling Jenrick, but she is undoubtedly weakened after this news and her frontbencher looks considerably lighter. Is this an inflection point for the Conservative party? And what role will Bobby J play in Reform – could he be their new shadow chancellor? Oscar Edmondson, Tim Shipman and James Heale discuss a hectic day on the British right. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Inside Jenrick & Reform's shotgun marriage

Robert Jenrick joins Reform

From our UK edition

Robert Jenrick has rounded off an extraordinary day on the British right by formally joining Reform. Sacked by Kemi Badenoch at 11 a.m., he was in Milbank Tower announcing his defection at 4:30 p.m. A grinning Nigel Farage gave him a brief introduction – only for there to be an awkward 30-second pause before Jenrick finally appeared. The Newark MP gave a 15-minute speech which set out his reasons for quitting. After a fairly dry first half which echoed his 2024 leadership campaign – with a detailed litany of state capacity failings – he then moved onto the crucial section of the speech: a denunciation of the party he served for two decades.

Is Jenrick joining Reform?

From our UK edition

8 min listen

Kemi Badenoch has sacked Robert Jenrick from the shadow cabinet, removed the Tory whip and suspended his party membership. In a video on X she claims, ‘I was presented with clear, irrefutable evidence that he was plotting in secret to defect in a way designed to be as damaging as possible’. The Tories compiled a bundle of evidence that included a dinner between Jenrick and Nigel Farage last month, and the fact that he had discussed switching to Reform with at least two allies. It is understood that he left a copy of his defection speech lying around, which included passages criticising Conservative colleagues. Is this – as we all suspect – the prelude to perhaps Reform's biggest coup yet? Tim Shipman and James Heale discuss. Produced by Megan McElroy and Oscar Edmondson.

Kemi sacks Robert Jenrick

From our UK edition

Kemi Badenoch has sacked Robert Jenrick from the shadow cabinet, removed the Tory whip and suspended his party membership. In a video on X she claims she was ‘presented with clear, irrefutable evidence that he was plotting in secret to defect in a way designed to be as damaging as possible’. The Tories compiled a bundle of evidence that included a dinner between Jenrick and Nigel Farage last month, and established that he had discussed switching to Reform with at least two allies. It is understood that he left a copy of his defection speech lying around, which included passages criticising Conservative colleagues. Nick Timothy is also understood to be replacing him in his role as shadow justice secretary.

Starmer’s gags fail to save his PMQs

From our UK edition

It used to be said that Keir Starmer had a magic lamp, such was his fortune in opposition. If this genie did exist, it has long since crossed the floor. The U-turn on digital ID last night gave Kemi Badenoch yet another stick with which to beat Starmer at today's session of PMQs. The Tory leader took full advantage of it with relish. 'Can I start by saying that I welcome the Prime Minister's U-turn?', she began. 'I feel like I say that every week'. Starmer's response was to seek refuge in humour, deploying a series of gags to mixed effect. 'They had more positions in 14 years than the Karma Sutra', he guffawed. 'No wonder they're knackered – and they left the country screwed.

What’s the future of the Scottish Tories?

From our UK edition

19 min listen

The leader of the Scottish Conservatives, Russell Findlay MSP, sits down with James Heale to look ahead to May's pivotal Holyrood elections. He pushes back against the threat from Reform, arguing that Nigel Farage is trying to be 'all things to all people', and he is scathing about the lack of loyalty shown by those who have defected from the party – not just to Reform, but to the Liberal Democrats too. But with the collapse of the support Labour received in the 2024 general election – which Findlay calls their 'loveless landslide' – why aren't the Tories benefitting more? Plus, how did being the victim of a vicious acid attack in 2015 shape his politics? Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Why Ed Davey is happy being boring

From our UK edition

15 min listen

The Liberal Democrats have unveiled a new strategy on the NHS. Sir Ed set out his big, bold plan this morning: scrapping the UK–US pharmaceutical deal to redirect £1.5 billion into social care. It sounds like a substantial sum – until you remember it amounts to less than 1 per cent of the NHS’s annual budget. In today’s podcast, the team discuss why Ed Davey is leaning into being deliberately boring, in an effort to appeal to the perceived sensibilities of Middle England. Meanwhile, with the dust settling after Nadhim Zahawi’s defection, is Reform at risk of losing its outsider appeal, given that his resignation from government caused such a public outcry? Megan McElroy is joined by Luke Tryl, UK Director of More in Common, and James Heale.

Why Ed Davey is happy being boring

From our UK edition

The Sopranos is not an obvious starting point when discussing the Liberal Democrats. But a TV programme about mafia, murder and manicotti offers a useful analogy for comparing Ed Davey’s strategy to that of Reform UK. David Chase, the Sopranos creator, recalls once meeting a TV exec who wanted LOP – ‘Least Offensive Programming’, the idea that the more palatable and likeable a character, the more they would be popular with audiences. It is a theory which Davey seems to have taken to heart, donning cricket whites and wetsuits in a bid to appeal to the perceived sensibilities of Middle England. His party’s policy offering is carefully calibrated not to offend the tastes of such voters. Today’s offering was a classic of the genre.

Zahawi defects: are Reform becoming Tories 2.0?

From our UK edition

15 min listen

How many Tories is too many? That’s the question Westminster is asking after the unveiling of Reform’s latest defector. Nadhim Zahawi, Boris Johnson’s brief-lived Chancellor of the Exchequer, is Nigel Farage’s latest recruit. He told journalists that the UK had reached a ‘dark and dangerous’ moment, and that the country needed ‘a glorious revolution’. But are Reform just turning into the Tories 2.0? And what will Zahawi’s role be – is he the elusive shadow chancellor Farage has been searching for? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Tim Shipman and James Heale. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.