Isabel Hardman

Keir Starmer is back at the despatch box for Prime Minister’s Questions today and his honeymoon period is unquestionably over. He will face hostile questions on the winter fuel payment, on arms export licences to Israel, and on whether Labour plans to raise taxes in the autumn budget. And he will want to talk about the Grenfell Inquiry, which is publishing its report shortly. That report will be uncomfortable reading mainly for Conservatives, but the recommendations will be Labour’s to implement – or not  –and the pressure will be on the Prime Minister to accept them in full.  Starmer has made public injustices and the system not working for ordinary people one of his major themes, and he will want to expand on that today.

David Lammy has just announced that Britain is suspending 30 arms export licenses to Israel. The Foreign Secretary told the House of Commons that after a review of international humanitarian law, he was left with no choice but to conclude that there was a risk of a number of weapons being used to commit or facilitate the violation of the law. He said: It is with regret that I inform the House today that the assessment I have received leaves me unable to conclude anything other than that for certain UK arms exports to Israel, there does exist a clear risk that they might be used to commit or facilitate a serious violation of international humanitarian law.

Could Labour be about to water down its removal of the winter fuel payment for pensioners? The chorus of muttering is getting louder in the party about restricting it to those on pension credit or other means-tested benefits, with backbenchers saying they have been shocked by the volume of letters from pensioners about it. This week, Rachael Maskell called on the government to think again about the policy after the new energy price cap went up, and now Harriet Harman has intervened with her own suggestion. Baroness Harman politely offered a compromise in which ‘they decide to make a different cut-off point’. Harman doesn’t tend to criticise her party in public: she always tries to take a positive line about its leadership or stays quiet.

A much bigger story than Rachel Reeves cancelling the winter fuel payment is her announcement today that she is finally killing off the beleaguered cap on social care costs. Reeves told the Commons that the Conservative government had not funded its reforms to social care, so they weren’t going to happen. She said: Adult social care was also neglected by the previous government. The sector needs reform to improve care and to support staff. In the previous parliament, the government made costly commitments to introduce adult social care charging reforms, but they delayed them two years ago because they knew that local authorities were not ready and that their promises were not funded, so it will not be possible to take forward those charging reforms.

One of the big themes of Keir Starmer’s government could well end up being accountability in the public sector, which sounds boring until you look at examples of where that is sorely lacking. Take the Care Quality Commission (CQC), the NHS regulator. Today, Health Secretary Wes Streeting declared it ‘not fit for purpose’ after an interim report found some hospitals had never received a rating, that others hadn’t been reinspected for up to ten years, and that some inspectors seemed to have even less experience of healthcare settings than the average member of the public. That included inspectors who had never been in a hospital before, and ‘an inspector of a care home who’d never met a person with dementia’.

Another week, another Prime Minister’s Questions featuring Keir Starmer and Rishi Sunak arguing across the Commons. Except, of course, the men had swapped sides, with Starmer taking his first session as prime minister, and they were – possibly for the first time ever – quite nice to each other. All the old grudge match lines had gone. There were plenty of references to how civil they were being to each other, plenty of ‘I’m glad to hear the prime minister’ and ‘I will reach out across this House’.  Sunak focused all his questions on Ukraine and international affairs, which made it much easier for the two men to be pleasant.

We know that the NHS is broken: Wes Streeting announced that it was now the official policy of this government when he entered the Department of Health and Social Care. Today he had a chance to elaborate on just what exactly he thought was broken – and of course to point the finger at who was responsible. It was his first departmental questions in the House of Commons, and like every other incoming Secretary of State, Streeting made sure he laid on the ‘Tories broke this’ line as thickly as cream on a scone. Pointing to shadow health secretary Victoria Atkins, he described the hospital building programme: I once again say to the Opposition that they handed over an entirely fictional timetable and an unfounded programme. The hon.

Labour are now making daily pronouncements on the latest policy area where the last government left things in a worse state than it let on. The latest is immigration. Yvette Cooper came to the Commons this afternoon to make a statement on border security. Even though she is now the Home Secretary, she sounded strikingly like she was still in opposition. She was the one responsible for that delay. Anyway, Cooper told the Commons that ‘I have reviewed the policies, programmes and legislation that we have inherited from our predecessors and I have been shocked by what I have found.’ The added: ‘Not only are there already serious problems but on current policies the chaos and costs will likely get worse.