Society

James Forsyth

The Hunt for a new Tory party chairman

Even if Caroline Spelman is completely exonerated by the Parliamentary Standards Commissioner she’ll still be moved from her post as party chairman. The party needs a better media communicator in the job in the run-up to an election. If the reshuffle rumours are to be believed, Jeremy Hunt is in pole position to replace her. Hunt is one of the most effective members of the shadow cabinet and comes across well on TV and radio. But a top trio of Cameron, Osborne and Hunt is too similar. Three southern, Oxford educated public school boys are always going to find it hard to reach certain sections of the electorate. Apparently that

All about timing and delivery

Great timing by Dave with his environmental proposal today.  After the Heathrow announcement yesterday, talk of a greener national infrastructure by the Tory leader is sure to irk a few Labour MPs, and could set the political dividing lines in his party’s favour.  What’s more, the Tory policy idea – a £1 billion “investment” in what would apparently be a smarter, cleaner, more efficent National Grid – sounds like something that even the envirosceptics can sign up to; depending, of course, on where that £1 billion comes from. Marks also have to be given for delivery.  Today’s announcement is set to be the UK’s first online policy launch – and

James Forsyth

Lies, damned lies and league tables

According to the school league tables published today no pupils at Eton are “achieving 5 A*-C GCSEs including English and maths”. How can that be? Well, Eton like various other top private school have abandoned GCSEs in certain subjects and instead have their pupils take international GCSEs which don’t count in the league tables. IGCSEs, though, are far harder than their British counterparts, more like the old O-Levels than GCSES. For all the talk from Balls and Brown about “social mobility”, they have presided over the erection of a new barrier to social mobility: the rise of an alternative set of exams that are more highly valued by universities and employers

James Forsyth

It’s a small world at the top

Ben Smith spots a passage in Michael Wolff’s Murdoch biography which might explain why Murdoch’s New York Post is so enthusiastically backing Caroline Kennedy: “As Rupert Murdoch begins to plot to get the Wall Street Journal, he’s also worried about getting Grace into private school in New York. He wants her to go to Brearley, where [an older daughter] went. He recruits Gary Ginsberg, who knows the Kennedys, to help him get Caroline Kennedy, a Brearley Alumna and board member, to write a letter on Grace’s behalf.” The other thing this snippet makes you think is how absurdly competitive and socially-based the admissions process is at these New York private

Digby Jones gives the civil service a kicking

Sounds like Lord Digby Jones, the former trade minister, gave a fiery performance during his select committee appearance earlier.  This quote on his experience of the civil service is simply too good not to reprint:  “I was amazed by how many people frankly deserved the sack – and yet that was the one threat they never worked under, because it doesn’t exist as long as they have not been criminal.” And now Gordon Brown’s waded into the fray, issuing this through his spokesman: “I think you will find that the civil service is full of honest, decent people who work hard.” I guess that’s ok then… Hat-tip: The Telegraph’s Christopher Hope

How much longer can Brown and Mandelson rein in Labour’s discontents?

After John McDonnell’s suspension from the Commons today, it’s time for another installment of Rebellion Watch.  Truth is, numerous Labour MPs aren’t behind the Heathrow proposal – indeed, Brown’s said to be pretty much the only Cabinet member who truly supports it – but they’re being won over, for now, by the prospect of it creating more jobs as well as, I’m sure, by the notion of causing difficulties for the Tories.  By all accounts, much of the behind-the-scenes persuasion is being done by Peter Mandelson – but can the Enobled One hold back all the tides of rebellion as 2009 progresses? It’s not looking promising for Brown ‘n’ Mandy.  As well as

Bad news buried under the third runway

Just to point out an important post by Sam Coates over at Red Box.  Turns out the House has chosen today, when the airwaves are dominated by the Heathrow announcement, to publish an audit of MPs’ expenses (pdf here).  I’ll leave you to check out the details in Sam’s post, but it’s now looking less likely that we’ll see a full publication of expenses or, indeed, any proper restrictions introduced.  All in all, I wouldn’t be too surprised if the Government’s quite pleased that John McDonnell has been suspended from the Commons for protesting the Heathrow expansion.  There’ll be even less room in the papers for these dispiriting cover-ups to be exposed.

James Forsyth

Damming with faith praise

“If you compare him with an average Russian bureaucrat you’re laughing.” A hilarious–—perhaps unintentionally so—assessment of Gordon Brown from Alexander Lebdev, who is reportedly the new owner of the Evening Standard.

Will Mandy’s latest scheme kickstart the car industry?

What to make of Peter Mandelson’s latest idea to prop up the car industry, as splashed by today’s Times?  Basically, the plan is that the Bank of England will use taxpayers’ cash to back the loans offered by finance companies to potential car buyers.  And the hope is that this will free up credit and stimulate demand for all those cars sitting unsold on garage forecourts across the nation.  There’s much room for initial mischief from the Opposition – “Gordon Brown: buying someone else’s car with your money,” that kind of thing – but greater damage will come if the plan simply doesn’t work.  And there’s certainly potential for that. To my mind, it all comes

It’s a matter of rhetoric for Miliband

There’s plenty of hoo-haa about David Miliband’s “‘War on Terror’ was wrong” article in the Guardian today.  But, truth be told, it’s probably less significant than it first appears.  You see, Miliband the Elder is talking rhetoric – he’s simply saying that the phrase ‘War on Terror’ was the wrong one to use because of what it implies; because it panders to unnuanced “us and them” thinking; because it suggests that the only solution is a military one.  In a week that George Bush admitted some of his rhetoric “has been a mistake”, that sounds fairly uncontroversial to me. Fact is, whatever name it’s given, Western strategy is increasingly premised

James Forsyth

The Ken Clarke conundrum

Having let the Ken Clarke hare run, the Tory leadership are faced by what happens to him dominating reshuffle coverage. If after this Cameron doesn’t bring him back there’ll be a lot of headlines about Cameron bowing to pressure from the right. But if Clarke does return, then the press—egged on by Mandelson—will start speculating about ‘Tory splits.’ (If Clarke does return, expect to see rather a lot of this pic from the Britain in Europe launch.) Cameron’s dilemma is that Clarke’s return would boost the party in opposition—he is, whatever his faults, a highly effective media performer—but hinder it in government. The problems Clarke might cause would not be

Who’s for Ken?

With the debate over whether Cameron should bring back Ken Clarke raging away in Westminster, we’ve put together this list of prominent commentators who have publically come out for or against the idea – along with links to their articles on the matter.   All for posterity’s sake, you see.  Do let us know in the comments section if we’ve missed anyone out: Pro-Clarke Jackie Ashley – The Guardian Iain Martin – The Telegraph Iain Dale – Iain Dale’s Diary Richard Littlejohn – Daily Mail Michael Portillo – The Times The Telegraph Peter Mandelson, apparently… Anti-Clarke Fraser Nelson – The News of the World (incomplete column online), and Coffee House Andrew

Lansley gives Ben Bradshaw’s Brownies the response they deserve

Looks like Ed Balls isn’t the only one who’s trying out Brownies based on Tory spending commitments at the moment.  Health Minister Ben Bradshaw is doing his best to spread the idea that the Tories would cut health spending, despite Cameron’s commitment to “protect” real terms increases in the health budget.  He tried to push the Brownie in a letter last month, which I publish at the bottom of this post.  First, though, Andrew Lansley’s reponse – which was sent out today, and which is a textbook example of how to deal with the little manipulations that Brown & Co. seems to specialise in: Ben Bradshaw MP Minister of State for Health Services The Labour

Reshuffle rumours ahoy!

Plenty of Tory reshuffle speculation swirling around the Westminster washbowl today, but this from Ben Brogan is worth highlighting: “News just in: Cabinet ministers heading for PMQs seem to think that Iain Duncan Smith is about to be brought back to the Shadow Cabinet to take on James Purnell. Must be a spot of fun following the Hague thing. Cue jokes about “bald beasts” and Michael Howard returning to take on home affairs.” If IDS were to return to the frontline, many would see it as a deserved reward for his excellent work with the Centre for Social Justice.  He certainly has the political and intellectual nous to take on

James Forsyth

The Tories try to bring Hague’s vague role into focus

Over Christmas, William Hague’s standing in the party and David Cameron’s authority took a beating from reports that the shadow foreign secretary was prepared to resign rather than give up his outside interests. Today’s joint Cameron-Hague interview in The Sun can be seen as an attempt to move on from that. In an attempt to minimise the part-time issue, Hague tells George Pascoe-Watson, “I have been drastically cutting my outside interests. That will continue. There won’t be a lot left by the time we are approaching the election.” For his part, Cameron tries to show that Hague is not a semi-detached member of the team by stressing that Hague is his

Are there only two members of the Shadow Cabinet who can command the media spotlight?

An article in today’s Times says that a return to the Tory front bench for Ken Clarke is looking increasingly likely.  But a more striking revelation is contained in this paragraph: “The Tory leader believes that the former Chancellor is the only senior Conservative, other than himself and George Osborne, who can command the media spotlight.” To my eyes, there are a bunch of “senior conservatives” – including Michael Gove, Jeremy Hunt, Eric Pickles and Nick Herbert – who are, at the very least, effective media performers.  Whether or not they “command the media spotlight” is a slightly different question.  But – as James suggested a couple of weeks ago

James Delingpole

Batle of the sexes

Is it just me or is Fiona Bruce incredibly, incredibly annoying? I only ask because I didn’t have a view on the subject till I was watching her present The Real Sir Alan Sugar (BBC2, Sunday) and on at least two occasions found myself so cross it was all I could do not to smash my TV to tiny pieces with a claw hammer. The first occasion was when — while breakfasting flirtatiously with Sir Alan on his private jet — Fiona decided to show what a hard-headed reporter cum serious feminist she was by taking umbrage at Sir Alan’s supposed neanderthal sexism. Apparently he has a habit of asking

The unselfish gene

On Kindness, by Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor Whenever I say to someone that I do not believe that there is a universal human right to healthcare, that person always asks whether, then, I want to see people dying in the street from treatable disease. I in turn ask that person whether he can think of any reason for not allowing people to die in the street other than that they have a right to treatment. The fact that, as often as not, the person has great difficulty with this question suggests not only that our state, but our minds and moral imaginations have become highly bureaucratised. There is no