Politics

Read about the latest UK political news, views and analysis.

Help Purnell

It is one of the oddities of politics that a Labour government can sometimes get away with announcing policies which, had they come from the mouth of a Conservative minister, would have provoked howls of anger. So it is with welfare reform. Whenever Mrs Thatcher’s government proposed to make benefit claimants actually do something for their handouts rather than languish in bedsits in Hastings and Margate, as was the common practice in the 1980s, the resulting rage and charges of heartlessness smothered serious reform — with dreadful consequences. In pockets of the country unemployment has become hereditary, and the idea of working for a living an entirely alien concept. The

The White House will be run like Chicago

Clinton brought Arkansas to Washington, and Texas followed Bush. Now, says Alexandra Starr, Obama is bringing the take-no-prisoners politics of Al Capone’s city to the Beltway Washington may not have had an architectural makeover in more than two centuries, but the city’s political culture has shown a chameleon-like ability to change with each incoming administration. When Bill Clinton arrived from Little Rock, Arkansas 16 years ago, for example, he brought a penchant for late-night rambling discussions and a Southern disregard for keeping to schedules. Most of his underlings emulated those attributes, imbuing the town with a swing-by-the-seat-of-your-pants ethos. President George W. Bush’s Lone Star state heritage came through in his

Fraser Nelson

Squeezing the poor until the pips squeak

When Gordon Brown urges the bank to “pass on” the interest rate cut, why doesn’t he lead by example with his very own state-owned mortgage company, Northern Rock? Because NR is up to no good – and the Financial Services Authority has given us a rare glimpse into exactly what its game is. It released a banking report (here, note 9.47) which confirmed that NR’s loyalty is to the state: that is to say, it must “focus on repaying its government loan”. Deplorably, it is doing this by deliberately overcharging those too poor to get a better deal. Here’s now it works. Many millions (including myself) took up NR’s low

Theo Hobson

The C of E should follow John Milton’s lead

It’s the debate of our day, the meta-debate if you like. It unites the issues of Muslim extremism, creationism, irritable atheism, faith schools, Britishness, the future of the monarchy, Sarah Palin, Ruth Kelly: all the juiciest talking points. The radio show The Moral Maze seems to return to it with increasing frequency: Michael Buerk has developed a special sort of quizzical-weary tone with which to pick at its entrails. I’m talking, of course, about the Place-of-Religion-in-Public-Life debate. This is a debate that’s gradually turning into a culture war: over the past few years we’ve seen both sides digging deeper in, and the middle ground becoming less habitable. How can this

We must break down the Berlin Wall in schools

He who controls the past, George Orwell argued, controls the future. Orwell’s warning resonates all the more powerfully as the government considers the erasure of history from the primary curriculum. A sense of the past is a precious thing. And not to know history, as Cicero argued, is to remain a child for ever. Orwell, as a student and satirist of the Soviet system, would have appreciated the special value of knowing what passed for progress in the communist world. And a knowledge of Soviet history is particularly precious when it comes to examining what’s happening in our education system at present. One of the grim everyday realities of life

Alex Massie

Economic Policy Trust Test: Labour or the Germans?

A good old-fashoned rumpus is developing. Seems as though the Germans, fed up with being sneered at by Godron Brown and irritated by the Prime Minister’s pretensions to have “saved the world” have decided to poke the PM in the eye. As Peer Steinbruck, the SPD Finance Minister told Newsweek: We have a bidding war where everyone in politics believes they have to top up every spending program that’s been put to discussion. I say we should be honest to our citizens. Policies can take some of the sharpness out of it, but no matter how much any government does, the recession we are in now is unavoidable. When I

Alex Massie

No! Not the Bore Worms…

You remember the line don’t you? “Flash, Flash, I love you, but we only have 14 hours to save the earth.” And you’ll remember the Labour posters promising “Not Flash, Just Gordon”? Well, they ditched that idea today. Or at least the Prime Minister did as this unfortunate slip at Prime Ministers’ Questions demonstrates: Now Labour’s approach to the financial maelstrom is pretty simple: find something to do, do it and then accuse anyone who asks any questions of adopting a “do-nothing” approach. Never mind that do-nothing might be preferable to punting everything on black or, rather, red. Still, the Tories are in a minor pickle: Jeremy Paxman gave wee

Lloyd Evans

The Doormat PM toils through PMQs

It was a tale of two howlers at today’s PMQs. The Prime Minister made the fatal mistake of pausing at the wrong moment. David Cameron had probed him about the recapitalised banks’ failure to lend to small businesses and Brown stood up, swelling confidently into one of his self-congratulatory orations. ‘Not only did we save the world banking system,’ he meant to say but a half-second pause after ‘world’ meant that ‘banking system’ never came out. ‘Not only did we save the world …’ The Tories howled and jeered for a full minute while the Speaker, playing the diligent killjoy, flapped his hands to calm them down. Brown recovered, sort

Fraser Nelson

A good place for Cameron to start

I’ve just come back from the Policy Exchange party, which had an austerity feel to it: smaller guest list, no bubbly. And David Cameron gave a good, but rather low-key speech where he said he was pleased that his speech at LSE today went past with no tomatoes being thrown. LSE has a left-wing reputation, Cameron said, so he was pleasantly surprised to see queues around the block. The LSE does have a reputation as a hotbed of leftism. But it is also the spiritual home of fiscal conservatism.  It was here that Frederick von Hayek came in the 1929 invited by Lionel Robbins. The two of them built the

Ever wondered who’s wearing your cast-offs?

Katrina Manson explores Africa’s extraordinary multimillion-pound trade in secondhand clothing, much of it imported from Britain and the United States Christmas might be a time for cheer and charity but, just as emotionally consuming, it’s also a time for clear-outs. As the annual wander through your wardrobe beckons, consider what happens to cast-offs dispatched to your nearest charity shop. Drop off a wardrobe has-been and it may turn up in the dusty pathways of Benin or the nightclubs of Nairobi. Babies in the world’s poorest countries wear tops emblazoned with ‘Little Miss Posh’; men in ex-war zones strut about in vests carrying urban-chic slogans such as ‘Rebel’; the odd bit

A reminder | 9 December 2008

Just to remind CoffeeHousers of our Q&A with Theresa May.  We’ll keep it running until Thursday, before selecting the best questions for the shadow leader of the Commons.  You can submit your questions by heading over here.

Fraser Nelson

Three hours’ worth of hot air

That three-hour debate on Damian Green really was a waste of time. A poll of MPs shows 30 want Michael Martin to go, but how many say that to in the chamber? Nada. We have some honesty from  Douglas Carswell and Bob Marshall-Andrews and that’s about it. Some rebellion. All they were left with was innuendo. Dennis MacShane saying that sergeants don’t fall on their swords, officers do. Wink, wink. And that was about as tough as it got. So this pointless committee of grandees will go off, boycotted by the Tories and the LibDems, to report after Green has been cleared. And report on what? We know pretty much

Just in case you missed them… | 8 December 2008

Here are some of the posts made over the weekend on Spectator.co.uk: Fraser Nelson writes on tackling the giant evil of idleness, and outlines how CCHQ is being affected by the credit crunch. James Forsyth asks whether a fourth term Labour government would take Britain into the Euro, and speculates whether a Cabinet minister thought Gordon Brown was breaking the law. Peter Hoskin wonders whether the Speaker will stand for a third term. Clive Davis adds another entry to his notebook. And Americano describes the Republican predicament.

Fraser Nelson

Tackling the giant evil of idleness

This year has seen a gruesome series of stories bearing out the Broken Society narrative, starting with teenagers shooting each other and ending with Karen Matthews abducting her own daughter in search of a McCann-style reward. Look at most of these stories, including Baby P, and there is a common theme: they take place in welfare ghettoes, those oases of deprivation in every British city. While we should condemn the evil, we should also condemn something the system that incubates the evil. There was a reason that Beveridge called idleness a “giant evil”. As I say in my News of the World column today when you pay people to do

Fraser Nelson

CCHQ gets crunched

When news of the Tory budget cut was broken by Conservative Home it was spun as a prudent cost-cutting. Yet there is (as ever, with CCHQ) plenty of comic chaos behind the scenes. The basic problem was overspending in the boom years. Last year the cash was flowing in from bankers who could easily spare £50,000 and would pay even more to touch the hem of David Cameron. Things were going so well that, according to one version I’ve heard, David Cameron personally added £2 million to the budget, saying the party had to spend to get more cash. Other sources say it wasn’t Cameron, the machine just grew fat on

Charles Moore

The Spectator’s Notes | 6 December 2008

New Labour has always preserved from the hard Left the Leninist idea that the party (or, in Blair/Brown theory, ‘the project’) is the only reality to be respected. New Labour has always preserved from the hard Left the Leninist idea that the party (or, in Blair/Brown theory, ‘the project’) is the only reality to be respected. All the other institutions of society — above all, Parliament — are ‘superstructure’, so much flim-flam to be insulted, ignored and, if the chance presents itself, kicked into ‘the dustbin of history’. Everything about the arrest of Damian Green shows the effects of this process. Thus the police, corrupted by years of political pressure,

Alex Massie

Why will no-one support independence?

Commenter Rab O’Ruglen  doesn’t have much sympathy for the crisis afflicting the Tartan press: While I have every sympathy for those who find themselves in employment difficulties through no fault of their own I cannot say I have any sympathy for the Scottish print medium whatsoever.  If you are looking for an example of a people less well served by its press than Scotland’s, you have to go to totalitarian states to find it. It is incredible that when the Independence movement has reached the stage of forming a government, all-be-it a minority one, that every single one of Scotland’s public prints is pro-Union.  Sometimes vitriolically so.  These instruments in

A week in posts | 5 December 2008

Here is a selection of the posts made on Coffee House this week: Fraser Nelson reports on how the Speaker simply passed the buck on who was to blame for letting the police search Damian Green’s office and sets out the cases for fiscal autonomy for Scotland. James Forsyth speculates that David Davis might soon be asked to return to the shadow cabinet and suspects that comments about Obama thinking that Cameron is a lightweight came from Whitehall not Washington. Pete Hoskin wonders if the ad-hoc Tory Lib-Dem cooperation over Damian Green could lead to something more meaningful and notes Mandelson’s attempt to point the finger of suspicion at Cameron.

Fraser Nelson

Brown is trying to deflect blame onto the bankers

Why won’t the banks pass on the rate cut? Because there isn’t anything to pass on. And for the life of me, I can’t work out why they don’t point this out. The Bank of England base rate simply doesn’t mean the Bank of England is lending to banks at 2 percent. The plumping doesn’t work that way, not no more. British banks aren’t hoarding anything. They have no net assets. They have to borrow every penny they lend. Once they borrowed from the wholesale market, which has seized up. What cash is available comes at a hefty price. By means of illustration, the banks had to pay 12 percent