Politics

Read about the latest UK political news, views and analysis.

James Forsyth

How the government plans to shift Northern Rock

The details of the government’s latest scheme for Northern Rock shows just how long the taxpayer will be left supporting the stricken bank. The government will guarantee £25bn plus of bonds designed to cover both the loans given by the Bank of England and the bank’s need for cash to cover its operations with these bonds taking five years to repay. Rock shareholders are being increasingly sidelined. The BBC reports that once business plans re submitted by February 4th, it will be the Chancellor Alistair Darling who decides which bid to accept with the greatest emphasis being on which would allow taxpayer backing to be withdrawn soonest.  However, the government

How will the public react to being denied their referendum?

In an interview on today’s Politics Show, David Miliband reiterated the government’s opposition to a referendum on the EU Reform Treaty, claiming that: “The reformed Treaty is there for parliament to scrutinise and then to pass …. Obviously, people will put down an amendment and parliament will have to decide, but I don’t think this Treaty meets the bar of fundamental constitutional reform that should be the basis of having a referendum.” Miliband’s stance – although hardly surprising – is going to be disappointing for groups such as I want a referendum.com, as well as, I’m sure, for many Coffee-Housers. The question now is of how the wider public respond

Fraser Nelson

Brown won’t get his Tory split on Europe

William Hague was on Steve Richards’ GMTV show at 6am this morning (amazing what baby care does to your viewing habits) and asked The Question ahead of tomorrow’s debate: what would a Tory government do about a ratified EU Reform Treaty/constitution? He answered in almost the exact same words Cameron used on Marr last week. “In our view too much power would have been transferred from Westminster to Brussels, that it would lack democratic legitimacy for the reasons we have discussed, and that we would not let matters rest there and that is a position that Conservative MPs, as far as I can see, are very, very supportive of.” The

Money for art’s sake

On Tuesday, the Spectator’s Clemency Burton-Hill wrote an impassioned post on how the Arts Council of England’s recent funding settlement could spell death for numerous theatrical companies across the country.  Many media outlets have run similar pieces – pleading the case for this theatre or that – but few have been as persuasive as Richard Morrison’s excellent article in this weekend’s Times ‘What’s On’ section. Morrison reveals that the funding settlement will almost certainly put an end to the Birmingham Opera Company.  Under the direction of Graham Vick, this company has become a major critical darling but, more importantly, it defies the argument that opera – or even art more

Fraser Nelson

Delhi University up in arms over Brown’s “doctorate”

In last week’s Spectator, I disclosed, that Indian’s government was stuck for ideas as to what to give Gordon Brown as a present for his visit and ordered Delhi University to deliver an honorary PhD – for “Public services and academia.” When I spoke to No10 before that piece, they were unable to confirm that the award would go ahead. I speculated that this was because it may invite awkward questions such as “what as Brown ever achieved in the public services?” But the true controversy, according to The Hindu newspaper, is that the University academics are strongly against the plan – and of the 280 people present, just 15

James Forsyth

The question Hain must answer

Peter Hain has been cleared of breaching the Ministerial Code and many in Westminster think the furore over his failure to declare all the donations to his deputy leadership campaign will now die down. But Rosa Prince points out over at the Three Line Whip yesterday’s decision actually raises huge questions about Hain’s version of events and whether he can carry on as a minister. Hain has been cleared because he told his permanent secretary of the donations to his campaign including one from the GMB union of £10,000—which was not declared until last week—who he was negotiating with in his ministerial capacity at the time. But as Rosa notes,

James Forsyth

Has Labour found a way to avoid nationalising Northern Rock?

News has emerged from the PM’s trip to China that Alistair Darling will make a Commons statement about Northern Rock on Monday.  On Boulton and Co, Jonathan Levy reports that the word is that Goldman Sachs has advised the government to bundle up the money that is being using to support the stricken bank and sell it off as government bonds. The thinking is that this scheme would allow the taxpayer to recover their money and make the bank a more attractive proposition to private buyers. The BBC is saying that Virgin is now in pole position to take over the bank. Apparently, shareholder objections to the Virgin bid will be

Leaders, deputies–and elections

£180,000.00 or so doesn’t seem to buy you much of a political campaign these days. Peter Hain’s attempt at being deputy leader of the Labour party certainly ended in a lot of cheques being signed rather than in ballot papers being crossed in his favour. All that rather desperate spend only reinforced the impression that he was regarded as an outsider within the Labour movement as a whole-despite his status as a cabinet minister and MP of sixteen years standing. It’s all too easy though for a political campaign to run into such difficulties-because here the financial is an aspect of the personal. The moment a candidate puts his name

Backing McCain

In an excellent post over at Comment Central, Daniel Finkelstein lists the reasons why he thinks John McCain will win the Republican nomination.  Finkelstein’s second point is the most persuasive: “Second, I think that [John McCain] and Rudy Giuliani are the only Republicans with the remotest chance of winning in a general election.  I don’t think serious parties choose candidates who they know will lose.  Even though the conservative party establishment distrusts McCain I think they would be with him if things got tight and he was the only winner still available.”

James Forsyth

How hungry for power are the Tories? We’ll soon find out

How disciplined Conservative MPs are in responding to two issues coming up in the next few weeks will tell us a lot about how determined they really are to return to government. First, there’s the question of Parliamentarians pay. With Gordon Brown taking a tough-line, the Tories are obliged to do the same or open themselves up to a politically damaging line of attack. Iain Martin reports that the leadership has made the vote for a below inflation raise a three line whip and if a sizable number of MPs rebel then it will be a major embarrassment. Remember that it was the issue of MPs pay that gave Tony

The greying labour force 

As a follow-up to my post yesterday on the number of new jobs being occupied by the over-50s, I should point out that there’s a good piece on the matter by Melanie McDonagh in today’s Times.  McDonagh rightly argues that an increasingly grey component of the labour market is a positive development: “The notion that people are still being hired as they head for what was once, laughably, called the retirement age should cheer us up.  A workforce that brings together energetic Poles and hardy Brits of the war generation seems rather a good combination given the dearth of skills and any discernible work ethic among many school leavers …. 

James Forsyth

Might Ashdown’s Afghan appointment be collateral damage in the row between Britain and Russia?

The news that Paddy Ashdown is going to be a reconstruction supremo in Afghanistan, coordinating the military and development work, seems to be announced every few weeks. But it has never been officially confirmed that he will go and do the job. Now, Michael White reports that there is a danger that the appointment might get dragged into the row between Britain and Russia over the Litvinenko assassination. Michael White reports on his blog that, “The foreign secretary is anxious that the row doesn’t spill over to Iran or Kosovo, policy areas where we need Russian cooperation. One casualty could be Paddy Ashdown’s Afghan appointment by the UN on Monday.

Vocation calling

I was at a lunch this week to talk about the state of further education, in view of the Government’s plans to extend the school leaving age. It was generally agreed that further education and training are in a bit of a mess. “Does Gordon Brown actually know what vocational skills are?” someone asked. Who knows? But his Government could start showing that they understand the problem they need to tackle in non-academic terms by using the right language.  “Vocational” is the extraordinary term that has slipped into the vocabulary of politicians and educationalists to mean what we used to call practical, manual, technical skills. (That was before the expectation

Leave those schools alone

Is there anything more depressing in an age of prosperity, choice and freedom than the spectacle of an old fashioned public sector rationing system doing its bleak work? The criticisms levelled by Jim Knight, the schools minister, at the best schools over the implementation of the statutory admissions code are a horrible revival of the language of a bygone era when public goods were controlled by rigorously enforced queuing. And, in keeping with Fraser’s warnings, this is another example of the Brown government undoing the public service reforms of the Blair years (such as they were). The decision to make the admissions code statutory rather than advisory was a sop

Walls closing in on Ken?

The London mayoral race is entering a bitter period, with most of the invective being directed at Ken Livingstone.  Of course, we shouldn’t be too surprised when the Evening Standard, which has had its run-ins with Livingstone, produces headlines such as “Mayor ‘misled public over cash'”.  But – surprising or not – these headlines will still spoil Livingstone’s reputation with the voting public, and have already lead to condemnation from MPs of all three parties. More telling, though, is the fact that outlets such as the Guardian and New Statesman are adding their weight to the assault.  The Guardian’s criticism may be heavily mitigated but it exists nonetheless, with Dave

James Forsyth

Brown’s nationalisation nightmare

Iain Martin’s column this morning on the political dangers to Gordon Brown of nationalising Northern Rock is essential reading. As Iain argues, the danger for Brown is that Northern Rock could destroy his reputation for economic competence and set in the public mind the idea that he—unlike that nice Mr. Blair—is too left wing for modern Britain. One senior shadow cabinet minister tells Iain that: “It’s very him,”…” It’s what people think he came into politics to do all along: nationalise banks.” In The Independent, Steve Richards points out that neither Blair nor Brown have ever really grappled with the issue of ownership fearing that the whole issue was all

Fraser Nelson

Cameron gets the better of Brown in clash over Northern Rock

Great fireworks today over Northern Rock. Cameron started with sombre questions about taxpayers’ money involved – Can Brown guarantee the safe return of the taxpayers’ money given Northern Rock? Was he advised the liability could rise so high? Could it rise higher than £55bn? No answer. Brown tried his trick of last week of asking Cameron a question so often that Michael Martin intervened. “He doesn’t have to answer the Prime Minister’s question,” says Michael Martin. Not until the next general election, at any rate.   Then for Cameron’s coup de theatre. “I’ll tell you what you did. When it came to the need for a total guarantee of deposits,

James Forsyth

The US elections are about to turn dirty

Mitt Romney’s win in the Michigan Republican primary makes this Saturday’s Republican vote in South Carolina all the more important. If John McCain wins there, he should—barring disasters—end up as the Republican nominee. If he doesn’t, the race becomes wide open and Rudy Giuliani’s much criticised late state strategy could end up paying off. Politics is a dirty business in South Carolina and in 2000 John McCain was defeated in one of the nastiest campaigns ever conducted. No blow was too low. It was claimed that been turned while a prisoner of war in Vietnam and was really a Communist sleeper agent and that his adopted Bangladeshi baby was really