James Delingpole James Delingpole

Why did C.J. Sansom approve this moronic Disney+ Shardlake adaptation?

Plus: Clarkson's Farm is implausible and fake but I still love it

Sean Bean, barely even trying as Thomas Cromwell, in Shardlake. Image: Adrienn Szabo / © 2022 Disney+, Inc.  
issue 11 May 2024

What would C.J. Sansom have made of the Disney+ version of his novel series about 16th-century crookback lawyer Matthew Shardlake? Sadly, because he died just a few days before its release, we’ll probably never hear the full story. But this comment from the show’s producer offers a hefty clue: ‘Chris [Sansom] has been enormously generous and he wants more people to read the books, and this is such a good way.’

Sounds very much like Sansom accepted this atrocity of an adaptation as a necessary evil: his books had been stuck in development hell for nearly two decades (possibly, because his labyrinthine whodunits about monastic reform and court politics in Henry VIII’s England were considered a bit niche for mass audiences) and, in the end, he simply capitulated to moronitude.

But I wish he hadn’t. One of the things that make the Shardlake books so distinctive and admirable is their attention to period detail.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in