From the magazine

Urban gothic: I Want to Go Home, But I’m Already There, by Roisin Lanigan, reviewed

A rented London flat starts to exude hostility and malevolence – or could our impressionable heroine just be imagining it?

Sarah Ditum
Roisin Lanigan.  Robin Christian
EXPLORE THE ISSUE 12 April 2025
issue 12 April 2025

A horror story in three words: London property market. That’s the starting point for Roisin Lanigan’s brilliantly creepy debut novel, set in the sheer hell of being a young renter. Because once you’ve run the gamut of carbon monoxide-leaking boilers, coked-up estate agents, absentee landlords and frosty housemates (and been gouged in rental costs for the privilege), maybe a haunting isn’t a deal-breaker.

The main character, Aine, is adrift in her twenties with a vaguely online job and a prescription for unspecified mental health issues. She’s also pathologically passive: she ends up in London because Laura, her best friend from university, asks to flatshare and Aine can’t think of anything else to do. ‘So why not London? Nothingness might be there, too, maybe, but nothingness in a different environment, which was somethingness, she guessed.’

So when Laura decides to move in with her boyfriend, Aine inevitably drifts into cohabiting with her own, a young man called Elliott who harbours dreams of writing ‘Fleabag, but for boys’. (I have a feeling Lanigan may have met several real-life young men about town with exactly this dream. I know I have.) But despite Elliott’s clichéd ambitions, Aine considers him to be ‘usually right’ about things. The implication is that Aine cannot trust her own judgment at all. Which explains why she accedes to moving into the first available flat, despite the pervading sense of unease it gives her – a wrongness that only heightens once she’s actually living there. This is Shirley Jackson’s Hill House with better public transport links and access to a Sainsbury’s Local.

The flat ‘seems to repel any attempts at order in an almost malevolent way’.

GIF Image

You might disagree with half of it, but you’ll enjoy reading all of it

TRY 3 MONTHS FOR $5
Our magazine articles are for subscribers only. Start your 3-month trial today for just $5 and subscribe to more than one view

Comments

Join the debate for just £1 a month

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for £3.

Already a subscriber? Log in