Stephen Vines

Twelve steps to market meltdown

Stephen Vines says stock markets may seem wildly volatile at times of crisis, but they always follow a pattern

issue 22 November 2008

At times of financial crisis there is often a feeling that all the old certainties have been blown away. But what is striking about the entire history of stock-market crises is that they fall into a pattern — and this pattern makes it possible to make broad predictions about the panic cycles that have been remarkably consistent for more than a century.

American experts have dominated the sub-genre of identifying panic cycles, notably the market historian Charles Kindleberger and the economist Hyman Minsky. Based on their work, it is possible to identify the stages of the cycle — but not, to pre-empt the obvious question, to know exactly when it will end. So, here’s a 12-point guide.

Stage 1: all cycles can be said to begin with buoyant equity markets fuelled by a major development which stimulates at least one sector of the economy.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in