Clive James

Too Many Poets

issue 11 April 2015

Too many poets pack a line with thought But melody refuses to take wing. It’s not that meaning has been dearly bought: It has been stifled, by a hankering For portent, as if music meant too much. Sidney called this a want of inward touch.

True poets should walk singing as they weep, As Arnaut Daniel once epitomised; But nothing written will be worth its keep Composed by one who has not realised This to be true, and tested his own song On others, seeing if they listen long

Or turn away. Verse is a public act To that extent at least. As cruel as love, The wished-for gift declines to be a fact Except for the elect. The gods above Loll on their clouds and lazily look down To choose who gets the laurels of renown

Even if deaf. For them, it’s just a game, But not for us, and though there might well be Too many poets, we all nurse the same Faith in the virtue of our mystery.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in