The questions that need answering on the Chagos Islands deal

The art of policymaking is to chart a course through evolving circumstances. In the face of resistance, there are three options: resist and persevere in kind, adjust, or fold and abandon ship. The best policymakers make the correct decision at the right time. The British government is in such a moment with its attempt to cede the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. For months, it has elected the first option – even as the new Mauritian government rejected the terms of the original deal, and Donald Trump’s election victory promises to usher in an administration with dim views of the agreement. As the Chagossians condemned their exclusion from the negotiations, and Maldivian opposition exposed broad regional unease, one by one the arguments in favour collapsed.

Finally, the UK has rejected resistance and switched to adjustment. Yesterday, the Prime Minister’s spokesman confirmed that the government would now await the incoming American President’s blessing before finalising the deal.