Gareth Roberts Gareth Roberts

The last thing we need is more TV adaptations of Dickens

Olivia Coleman, Fionn Whitehead and Shalom Brune-Franklin in Great Expectations (Credit: Miya Mizuno/BBC/FX Networks)


Allow me to introduce you to a fun game you can play in your own parlour. You take it in turns for someone to shout out the title of a pre-21st century literary classic. The other player responds by giving the blurb of a 21st century television adaptation. It might go, for example; ‘Middlemarch!’ ’ A searing, never-more-relevant exposé of the rural chemsex scene starring Sophie Okonedo’. Or possibly; ‘Mapp and Lucia!’ ‘Benedict Cumberbatch and Eddie Izzard are locked in combat with the county lines gangs of the Sussex coast’. Or even: ‘Jane Eyre!’ ‘Lesley Manville and Cush Jumbo star in this accessible tale of the devastating mental health impacts of Tik-Tok addiction’. 

Nothing sums up this syndrome – the ‘relevant’ TV classic – better than the curious puff piece in the Telegraph this weekend for the BBC/FX’s new Great Expectations, to start next Sunday night. Yes, it’s Dickens. Oh no, groan, how stuffy, yawn. But wait – it’s funky! With swearing and violence and ethnic actors in it! 

A sexed-up Dickens with multi-ethnic casting is the most predictable thing, like Tuesday following Monday

Such articles are a mainstay of the broadsheet culture sections. They

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in