A toddler has gone missing on a council estate in London. Tom, a tabloid journalist, gets the whiff of a story that she may have been killed by another child, Lucy Green, the daughter of a young Irishwoman, Carmel. But Carmel is sunk in the misery of her first and only love affair in Waterford, which left her pregnant. She has never bonded with her daughter, seeing her as ‘a tiny, rabid, black-haired demon from hell’ and has remained obsessed by her erotic passion for her ex. Tom is equally obsessed by his need to get the big story that will make his name – even if it may not be true.
Megan Nolan, one of the new wave of strikingly talented young Irish writers, has spun Ordinary Human Failings around suffering, responsibility and lies. Carmel’s unplanned pregnancy has forced the Green family to leave Waterford for London. Tom is a familiar archetype, bright enough to understand that what he does is deplorable, even as he slaves to try and please his editor.
Back in the 1990s, when this novel is mostly set, journalists believed that everyone who was not another journalist or royalty or a celebrity were ‘peasants’. Charming and smarmy, Tom is soon making things so hot for the naive Green family that within hours they are holed up in a hotel in Mornington Crescent, paid for by the tabloid and awaiting their doom.
Nolan is witheringly funny about the moral squalor of this world. Nobody is interested in the dead child or in her popular parents – only in the family of ‘bad apples’ and foreigners. Tom’s editor sees the story as ‘a major state-of-the-nation-type piece’, the irony being that Carmel’s situation is just that – only the nation it typifies is not just Britain but Ireland, with its anti-contraception laws and Magdalen Laundries.
Comments
Join the debate for just £1 a month
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for £3.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just £1 a monthAlready a subscriber? Log in