Nick Cohen Nick Cohen

The conservative war on free speech

You cannot replace left-wing taboos with right-wing taboos

Ron DeSantis (photo: Getty)

The hopeful life and wretched death of Claudia Gavrilovna Popova during a previous age of extremes should speak to us now. Popova lived in Siberia in the years before the Russian revolution. She was a liberal who opposed the Tsarist empire – then, as now, was the world’s great fortress of reactionary power.

Popova was a wealthy landowner in Krasnoyarsk on the Yenisei River, who thought any enemy of the regime couldn’t be wholly bad. She gave free bed and board to Lenin when he was an obscure Marxist agitator. From the 1890s on, she helped hundreds of other revolutionaries the Romanov regime sent into exile.

Extremists always want to establish a binary conflict

Popova and the communists were against Tsarist autocracy. They might not agree on everything, but they appeared to share a common cause.

In 1917 Lenin seized power. By 1921, the civil war that followed the Bolshevik revolution had brought famine to Krasnoyarsk. Popova was in her 70s. Her wealth was long gone, and she was living on handouts. Her friends petitioned the local communists to help her, as she had once helped them.

They then revealed what they really thought of their benefactor. Popova was an aristocratic enemy of the people, they declared, and left her to starve to death.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in