Following my Sunday Telegraph column yesterday, I debated the Government’s plans to extend the pre-charge detention period from 28 days with Henry Porter at the end of the Today programme this morning. I was for, Henry was against.
I don’t like any restriction upon liberty, but I do not think this extension is being sought recklessly or for political effect. If anything, it is a terrible political gamble for Gordon Brown, whose Government is proceeding shambolically and is nowhere near achieving a consensus in the Commons. So I disagree fundamentally with Henry’s contention that this is all just a “virility test” for the PM, who is appealing to the “unlettered” part of the electorate or grandstanding to his backbenchers. The fact is that the Met, the Association of Chief Police Officers and the Independent Reviewer of terror measures, Lord Carlile, all agree that detention longer than 28 days is going to be necessary sooner rather than later – such is the sophistication and technological complexity of today’s global Islamist plots (those who doubt this should remind themselves of the Dhiren Barot trial).
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in