Jaakko-Kooroshy

The Afghan ‘mineral strike’ is just spin

John C. Hulsman and Jaakko Kooroshy explain that what looks like good news in Afghanistan is in fact just part of a propaganda war between Obama and Petraeus

issue 19 June 2010

This week, just as things were looking at their bleakest in Afghanistan — growing casualties and the damning report on the links between Taleban leaders and the Pakistani secret service — the Pentagon pulled a rare piece of good news out of the hat: Afghanistan, it turns out, is not only a poppy-growing paradise but also a mining El Dorado. Around $1 trillion worth of minerals has been discovered (says the US Geological Survey) and according to enthusiastic US and Afghan officials, this stunning potential could make mining the future backbone of the Afghan economy.

Well, hooray, then let’s not pull out so hastily, people have begun to say. Perhaps all those lives weren’t wasted; perhaps with the help of this newfound wealth, Kabul can secure democracy and keep the Taleban at bay.

But before we all get too excited, we should ask: is this really such an exciting discovery? Upon closer inspection, in fact, it tells us far more about the politically exhausted state of the American home front than it does about Afghanistan.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in