John Phipps

Tacky and incomprehensible: The Sandman audiobook reviewed

Audible's adaptation seems to have unearthed some kind of ur-crapness that was already present in the Gaiman comics, but which couldn’t be seen till now

Neil Gaiman hams it up horribly narrating Audible's adaptation of Sandman. Image: Rebecca Cabage / Shutterstock 
issue 19 September 2020

Listening to the tacky and incomprehensible audio-adaptation of Neil Gaiman’s graphic novel series Sandman, I couldn’t stop thinking about the 19th-century Swiss artist Rodolphe Töppfer.

Did Mr Töppfer realise what he was doing when he one day decided to draw a narrative in sequential panels with captions underneath? His satirical novel in pictures, Histoire de M. Vieux Bois, was published in 1837, and made its way to America five years later as The Adventures of Mr Obadiah Oldbuck. ‘Mr Oldbuck drinks ass’s milk’ reads one caption, and then overleaf: ‘His physician recommending exercise, he buys an Arabian courser.’ Riding the courser, ‘Mr Oldbuck increases his speed, advancing at the rate of ten leagues an hour.’ To modern eyes, Obadiah Oldbuck is something very recognisable indeed. He is the hero of the world’s first comic book.

Most of the script comes from Gaiman’s original comics. Why does it suddenly sound so crap?

The superhero era of comics began on the cusp of the second world war.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in