Douglas Murray Douglas Murray

Spies spy – get over it

Why do we whinge about surveillance, then moan about intelligence failure after a terror attack?

Photo by Keystone/Getty Images 
issue 12 October 2013

In the whole panoply of human idiocy is there anything so ridiculous as the outrage that occurs whenever people are reminded that spies spy? There was just such an outburst recently when Edward Snowden left his job as a contractor to the CIA and NSA, repelled, he said, by the discovery that surveillance programmes carry out surveillance. Snowden discovered that American and British intelligence agencies were involved in data trawling and was so horrified that he found it necessary to flee — first to the freedom-loving People’s Republic of China and then, to seek asylum, to Moscow. On the left of the political spectrum he is the new Julian Assange — though without the sex-crime charges.

Happily the new head of MI5, Andrew Parker, used his first public speech this week to inject some sanity back into the debate, and it was high time too.

As Parker reminded us, the intelligence services search for information not because they long to snoop on ordinary people, or feel a compelling need to read every email we send — but because they seek to thwart people who intend to harm us.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in