Mark Bostridge

Sisterly duty: The Painter’s Daughters, by Emily Howes, reviewed

In a celebrated portrait of his daughters, Thomas Gainsborough shows the older child protecting her sister from harm. The roles would be dramatically reversed in later life

‘The Painter’s Daughters Chasing a Butterfly’, by Thomas Gainsborough, c. 1756. [Bridgeman Images] 
issue 24 February 2024

The painter in the title of Emily Howes’s first novel is Thomas Gainsborough, famous, of course, as a great portraitist – ‘the curs’d face business’, as he once called it – and landscape artist. His daughters by his wife Margaret were Molly and Peggy, immortalised in half a dozen double canvases by their father. These family pictures allow us to intrude upon the sisters’ special intimacy as we follow their development from carefree girls playing in their native Suffolk to their emergence as fashionable young women in Bath and London society.

Ultimately, it’s the secret of Molly’s mental instability that keeps the two sisters inseparable

One of these paintings of the girls, edged about with the anxiety of a father, fearful for their safety, shows them aged six and five against a Suffolk landscape. Molly, cast as protector, is restraining her younger sister from chasing a butterfly that is about to land on a thistle.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in