The Spectator

Parents make the best parents

The over-zealousness of the government’s child protection racket is a human tragedy

issue 24 January 2004

Two developments this week demonstrate the absurdity, not to mention the inhumanity, of the government’s policy towards child-rearing. Firstly, sperm donors were informed that children conceived with the aid of their donations will be given the right to trace them. Secondly, the minister for children Margaret Hodge announced that it would be impossible to reunite thousands of children with parents from whom they were removed as a result of child-abuse prosecutions, even in cases where those prosecutions are ruled to be unsafe.

In the first case, the government is intent on thrusting some of the responsibilities of parenthood upon men who simply wished to help others and who believed the law protected their anonymity. In the second, Ms Hodge asserts the right of the state to decide how children should be brought up, even if the parents from whom they were removed on suspicion of child abuse are proven innocent. The child’s interest, said Ms Hodge by way of explanation, must come first.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in