Rachel Johnson

Not a level playing field

Rachel Johnson says the scandal over public exam results could end up with Oxbridge suing the Education Secretar

issue 26 October 2002

Tom Hill, a 19-year-old Marlburian (and son of parents with deep pockets, we hope), is suing the Oxford, Cambridge and RSA exam board (commonly known as OCR) that marked his A-levels for damages of up to £100,000. Now here’s an odder thing. If many more follow suit – and there is evidence they will – Oxbridge would have a good case for countersuing the Secretary of State for Education for undermining its own balance sheet and damaging its reputation. Isn’t the law fun!

Yes. Believe it or not, Oxford and Cambridge are enjoying what the City calls a ‘Ratner moment’, unique in their long and gilded history, and all because the introduction and marking of the new A-levels was an absolute horlicks. (If you don’t believe me, you can read up on the sorry mess on the Qualifications Curriculum Authority’s own website on www.qca.org.uk.)

But first, Tom Hill. As we now know, one exam board artificially lowered grades by hoiking the standards expected of candidates in the second part of A-levels, called A2.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in