Annie Walton Doyle

Ménage à trois: Day, by Michael Cunningham, reviewed

When Dan, his wife Isabel and her brother Robbie decide to spend lockdown together, claustrophobic domesticity develops into a painful love triangle

[Getty Images] 
issue 13 January 2024

Set over the course of the same April day, with morning, afternoon and night ascribed to consecutive years, Michael Cunningham’s Day is built around time’s march towards an inevitable ending. This feeling of being caught up in time and trapped by its onward force is shared by the novel’s small cast of characters. A married couple, Isabel and Dan Byrne, along with Isabel’s brother Robbie, are struggling with their floundering careers, ageing bodies and their place in the world. They are also balancing a painful platonic love triangle, with both Dan and Isabel more in love with Robbie than with each other.

The claustrophobic domesticity of the novel is amplified by its timespan: 2019-21. The pandemic is not overtly mentioned, but the conditions it creates of confinement and stasis intensify the family’s problems. By depicting the Byrnes before, during and after the crisis, Cunningham masterfully conveys the traumas and growing realisations experienced by everybody during Covid.

The feeling of being trapped both by lockdown and more generally by circumstances gives the novel an anxious undertone.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in