Mark Cocker

Man’s fraught relationship with nature extends back to prehistory

Archaeology indicates that the first migrations of hunters through Asia into the Americas and Australasia directly contributed to collapses in the Pleistocene megafauna

An artist’s impression of a woolly mammoth, the extinct genus of elephant from the Pleistocene era. [Getty Images] 
issue 14 September 2024

It is now almost a prerequisite of any dispute among environmentalists to recall a judgment offered by the literary critic Raymond Williams – that ‘nature’ is perhaps the most complex word in the English language. Attempts to unravel its meaning are fraught with challenge. Does it signify just the living elements of the biosphere, or does it include inanimate parts, such as mountains and rivers? The extreme heat of the Sun at its core makes it the place least hospitable to life – yet it is equally the source of the whole process. Perhaps the greatest of all associated questions is whether humans are subsumed within, or inexorably separated from, the Sun’s operations.

Jeremy Mynott’s book does an exceptional job of teasing out most of nature’s multiple meanings. In case we imagine that such issues are the preoccupations of a marginal sect, the author points out that climate change and the Sixth Extinction arise almost entirely from actions that assumed we are outside nature’s living fabric.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in