Alasdair Palmer

Life, liberty and terrorists

Charles Clarke tells Alasdair Palmer that the most important freedom of all is the freedom to walk the streets without being blown up

issue 17 December 2005

‘When it comes to the British courts,’ Charles Clarke insists, ‘I am a perpetual optimist.’ Which is fortunate, because he needs to be. We met on the day the Law Lords proclaimed that the government was not permitted to detain terrorist suspects on the basis of evidence which might have been extracted under torture. The government had been arguing that it needed to be able to use such information in court in order lawfully to detain people who were a threat to the British public. The Law Lords called that argument ‘disquieting’ and ‘disturbing’.

It was merely the latest in a series of reverses that the government’s policies to combat terrorism have suffered at the hands of the highest court in the land. Just before Charles Clarke became Home Secretary, the Law Lords delivered a blistering condemnation of the government’s policy of holding without trial foreigners suspected of terrorism. Lord Hoffmann went so far as to claim that ‘the real threat to the life of this country comes not from terrorism but from laws like these’.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in