The Spectator

Letters to the Editor | 21 October 2006

Readers respond to articles recently published in <span style="font-style: italic;">The Spectator</span>

issue 21 October 2006

Green realism

From George Monbiot

Sir: I realised long ago that we environmentalists cannot win. When we draw attention to the problem, we are told we are doom-mongers who refuse to accept that markets and human ingenuity can solve any difficulties caused by the overuse of resources. When we propose solutions, we are accused of being utopians who refuse to accept that nothing can be done.

In reviewing my book Heat (Books, 14 October) Tom Fort agrees that the changes I propose are necessary to prevent runaway climate change, but claims there is no chance they will be adopted. He sees bus lanes on motorways, offshore wind farms and stronger building regulations as the stuff of science fiction. To me, they seem rather mundane.

Mr Fort appears to believe that governments are incapable of pursuing policies that are costly, contentious and technologically demanding. So how does he explain the Iraq war?

George Monbiot
Oxford

Freedom vs equality

From Helen Johns

Sir: If David Miliband’s observation that we humans are ‘interdependent’ and co-operate with others to achieve our ends is the ne plus ultra of British political philosophy, then God help us (‘Cameron has substance — but it’s nonsense’, 14 October).

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in