Is ‘the Science’ scientific?
Sir: I hope that those in the highest places will have read and will act upon Dr John Lee’s excellent summary (‘The corona puzzle’, 28 March). His article cuts through the information overload and explains the surreal situation the country is now in. Draconian decisions have been made on the basis of ‘the Science’, apparently without realising that it is not science at all. The dangers of mere extrapolations, both mathematical and humanitarian, are widely understood. Modelling is, in this instance, a sophisticated form of extrapolation and even more dangerous. A specific model cannot be dignified with the term ‘science’ until it has withstood thorough testing.
We are suffering a crippling reaction justified by modelling based on seriously deficient starting data. The situation is so unprecedented that predictions must carry immense margins of error. This supposed ‘cure’ is vastly worse than the disease.
Neill G. Ross
Burnaston, Derbyshire
In praise of cleaners
Sir: I was pleased to see Dr Max Pemberton’s acknowledgment of the ‘absolute forefront’ role hospital cleaners have in the struggle against Covid-19 (‘The battle ahead’, 28 March).
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in