Michael Tanner

Janacek revealed

Cunning Little Vixen<br /> Royal Opera House, in rep until 1 April

issue 03 April 2010

Cunning Little Vixen
Royal Opera House, in rep until 1 April

Perhaps the most heartening feature of the British and especially the London operatic scene is the frequency with which Janacek’s operas are mounted now. His progress in that respect is comparable to that of Mahler, with whom he otherwise has mercifully little in common. Mahler’s symphonies soul-search, despair, exult, usually unconvincingly, or peter out, much more convincingly, in resignation and acceptance. Janacek has no more rosy a view of the world, specifically the human world, than Mahler, and in writing operas, which Mahler not only didn’t do but one can’t imagine his doing, he portrays individuals behaving in an impressively wide variety of ghastly ways, while virtue, or lovableness or warmth tend to be passive and oppressed or eliminated. In his bleakest opera, Katya Kabanova, which ENO has on at present in a mediocre production, the end is numbing. Oddly enough, the society that Katya presents is dominated by a woman so fearful that Janacek can hardly be bothered to characterise her, but in most of his operas he can find affection for nearly any woman, and less often for the males, who tend to be violent though weak, selfish and shallow.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in