Ian Thomson

It takes a trained ear fully to appreciate Indian music

Amit Chaudhuri sees the classical raga as the closest music comes to human speech — a weave of rhythmic cycles that is not a melody but a musical ‘essence’

Ravi Shankar playing the sitar in California in 1967. Credit: Getty Images 
issue 05 June 2021

At George Harrison’s 1971 concert for Bangladesh, awkwardly, the audience applauded after Ravi Shankar and his musicians had paused to tune their sitars and tablas. ‘If you appreciated the tuning so much,’ Shankar said, half in jest, ‘I hope you’ll enjoy the music even more.’ To the untrained ear, Indian music may sound unmelodious and directionless as it strays into apparent pre-concert tuning registers and monotony. Nonetheless, its transcendental Zen-like qualities impressed Richard Wagner, who was drawn to the spirituality and joss-stick mysticism (as he saw it) of the east. A devotional song performed by the Punjab Sufi vocalist Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan can soar as ecstatically as Parsifal. Indeed it’s hard not to levitate out of your seat when Khan and his team send up a prayer to Allah amid rhythmic hand-clapping. (The Bristol trip-hop outfit Massive Attack went so far as to re-mix a Khan incantation.)

According to the Sanskrit scriptures, a single musical note can contain within itself the entire universe.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in