John Oxley

Is there a house-building cartel?

The Competition and Markets Authority report on the housing sector should be a boost to the Yimby policy machine. It expressed grave concerns about the housing market operating like a cartel, and said that much of this was enabled by the current planning system. 

The CMA was tasked with looking at the housing market a year ago, because targets are consistently missed, prices are consistently rising, and there are allegations that tactics such as ‘land banking’ are used to drive up profits. The result was a strong indictment of the planning system as it currently stands. 

The report found that under-staffed planning departments, combined with a veto-heavy system, made getting permission to build protracted and unpredictable. This both limited the flow of new houses and squeezed small and medium-sized developers out of the market, enabling bigger players to bank massive profits and abuse their dominance. 

A further investigation was launched into eight of the biggest builders for potential anti-competitive practices.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in