Kate Chisholm

Impossible questions

‘I wish I knew,’ said the doctor in a rare moment of candour when asked, ‘What do you do with children who don’t want to take the tablets?

issue 07 August 2010

‘I wish I knew,’ said the doctor in a rare moment of candour when asked, ‘What do you do with children who don’t want to take the tablets?

‘I wish I knew,’ said the doctor in a rare moment of candour when asked, ‘What do you do with children who don’t want to take the tablets?’

He was talking about Tanya, an HIV-positive teenager who was refusing to take the life-giving anti-viral drugs he had recommended. She’d been born with HIV, her mother had died of Aids when she was still a baby, and she’d been raised by an aunt in ignorance of why she was always falling ill with chest infections. No one in the family wanted her to know.

Can Tanya be treated against her family’s wishes? Should she be told against their wishes? When does a seriously ill child have a say in their care plan? These were the decisions faced by the team of medical and legal experts on Inside the Ethics Committee, Joan Bakewell’s thought-provoking discussion programme which has returned for a short summer run on Tuesday mornings (produced by Beth Eastwood).

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in