Lara Feigel

Hero and villain: The Two Loves of Sophie Strom, by Sam Taylor, reviewed

A Jewish teenager is the victim of a Nazi arson attack in 1933. Alternative scenarios see him joining the French Resistance, and being recruited by the SS

Sam Taylor. [Credit: Kayla Brint] 
issue 27 April 2024

Counterfactual thinking can be compelling. We imagine love affairs missed out on, tragedies averted. What if I hadn’t boarded that bus or woken from that sleep? Sam Taylor throws this thinking into a vital moment in a young boy’s life that has massive, world- historical resonance.

Vienna, 1933. Nazi sympathisers burn down the flat of a Jewish family. Max Spiegelman, aged 13, escapes, but his parents burn to death. Or do they? In a parallel narrative, Max awakes from this dream into the very fire he’s just dreamed about, early enough to rescue his parents. Taylor alternates the stories of the Max whose parents survive and who remains on the right side of history, eventually joining the Resistance in Paris, and the Max who’s taken in by neighbours who rename him Hans and clothe him in the fortifying uniform of the Hitler youth and then the SS. Night after night, Max and Hans dream of each other, united and divided by their love of Sophie Strom, the French-German girl Max met just before the fire.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in