Francesca Peacock

Familiar scenarios: Our Evenings, by Alan Hollinghurst, reviewed

Public school crushes, adolescent freedoms at Oxford, first jobs and homosexual affairs in London – Hollinghurst’s latest novel seems like a reworking of all his previous books

issue 12 October 2024

There’s a certain pattern to an Alan Hollinghurst novel. A young gay man goes to Oxford. He’s middle class and riddled with suburban self-consciousness – a kind of complicated awareness of his non-posh failings and resulting subtle superiority. He meets another young man – possibly gay – who is posh. An intricate dance ensues of social slip-ups and huge townhouses in Notting Hill, bags of money and country piles. It’s a formula which can be transposed between Edwardian drawing rooms and 1980s parties with only the slightest changes. Sometimes our protagonist is the aristocrat himself; sometimes he even went to Cambridge. He’s always cultured – interested in poetry, theatre and Henry James.

Hollinghurst’s fiction was, for a period, radical. His Man Booker-winning The Line of Beauty (2004) exposed the hypocrisy among the political classes who tolerated homosexuality only when it went unmentioned, and turned a blind eye to the Aids crisis.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in