Peter Hoskin

Clarke’s calamity

Has Ken Clarke just signed his own political death certificate? Whether you agree with his liberal sentencing reforms or no’, there’s little doubting that the Justice Secretary has just stumbled quite emphatically on Radio 5. It looked bad enough for him when, discussing an idea to cut the sentences of those who plead guilty to sex attacks, he blustered that, “No, I haven’t put this idea to women who’ve been raped because I haven’t met one recently.” But then it turned even worse when a rape victim called in to describe her tragic case: she had been dragged through the courts for almost two years in search of justice, only for her attacker to plead guilty, have his sentence cut, and then go on to reoffend. Through tears, she described Clarke’s proposal as “a disaster”.

It crystallises what is a tremendous problem for the Tories. Clarke may have been correct in his observation that there is little equivalence between “17-year-olds having [consensual] intercourse with 15-year-olds” and what he called “forcible rape”, but his general policies do not chime with public sentiment.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in