James Delingpole James Delingpole

BBC1’s new Rebus is the kind of TV detective they just don’t make any more

How did such unreconstructed machismo make it on to the BBC?

Perfection: Richard Rankin as John Rebus in BBC1's new adaptation. Credit: BBC / Eleventh Hour Films / Mark Mainz 
issue 25 May 2024

Imagine a new series of Morse in which the real-ale-quaffing, jag-driving opera buff is turned into a speed-snorting mod on a pimped up Lambretta. Or – this one I’d actually like to see – jeune Poirot, featuring a clean-shaven habitué of fin-de-siècle Brussels absinthe dives. This may give you an inkling as to how upset one or two Rebus fans are about the Edinburgh detective’s latest TV incarnation.

Confusingly titled Rebus – as opposed to, say, Punk Rebus or Wee Rebussie – the series depicts a protagonist quite a bit younger than his former TV incarnations, grumpy, dishevelled Ken Stott and a mite-too-smooth John Hannah. Still only at the detective-sergeant stage of his career, he is a lot more aggressive – like maybe Begbie from Trainspotting would be in the unlikely event he ever joined the police – with a hair-trigger temper and a drinking problem.

This isn’t so much a faithful adaptation as a controlled demolition

This isn’t so much a faithful adaptation of Ian Rankin’s crime novels as a controlled demolition.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in