Kate Chisholm

Bach substitute

Janis (BBC Radio 2); Have Your Cake (BBC Radio 4)

issue 26 January 2008

It’s been really hard getting used to the idea that there’s no more Bach at eight on Radio Three. After 48 mornings, I’ve found myself well and truly addicted. The only way to combat the withdrawal symptoms seemed to be an immersion in something completely different, so I dutifully tuned into Radio Two in the hope of finding a cure. Brian Matthew, Jonathan Ross, Paul Gambaccini…nothing could shift that post-Bach mood of truculent dissatisfaction. Nothing, at least, until eight o’clock on Saturday evening when a wail of anguish cut through the airwaves like a cat out of hell: Janis Joplin, in extremis, singing, or perhaps I should say performing, ‘Take it! Take it! Take another little piece of my heart’. There’s nothing comforting about her music, no prospect of solace, but what a voice and what delivery. One minute belting it out, the next almost whimpering, ending in one enormous screech of pain.

I’m not sure that I’d have listened to this programme from choice, never being able to understand what was so appealing about such raw, over-the-top girning.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in