Henry Hitchings

Are the English exceptionally gullible?

It became common in the 18th century to speak of ‘English credulity’ and there was no shortage of hoaxers to exploit it, as Ian Keable’s enjoyable case histories show

‘English Credulity or the Invisible Ghost’. In a thronged room in Cock Lane two children lie in bed while the ghost of Fanny Lynes appears above them carrying a mallet (to make knocking sounds). [Alamy] 
issue 21 August 2021

The word ‘hoax’ did not catch on till the early 19th century. Before that one spoke of a hum, a frump, a prat or a bilk. But 18th-century Britain, even if not rife with talk of ‘hoaxes’, was full of incautious souls at risk of being bilked. James Graham, a Scottish quack, was able to charge infertile couples £50 a night to lounge in his Celestial Bed, which had a mattress lined with hair from stallions’ tails. The artist Ann Jemima Provis and her father, Thomas, caused embarrassment to the Royal Academy by conning its president, Benjamin West, into thinking they had stumbled on a rare manuscript that would allow him to emulate the luminous style of the Venetian masters. William Charlton painted black spots on the wings of a yellow butterfly and announced thathe had discovered a new species, which in due course found its way into the British Museum.

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in