Michael Dobbs is a charming, intelligent and self-effacing man, but you would not have guessed it from the blurb on the dust-jacket of his latest political thriller. ‘Michael Dobbs always makes an impact,’ it tells us.
How can he possibly have approved this guff?He has worked with prime ministers, written about kings, and always seems to be in the right spot at vital moments in history. His experiences have led him to be described as a man who, in Latin America, would have been shot.
Winston’s War has an intriguing plot, based on the real-life meeting between Guy Burgess and Winston Churchill at Chartwell at the time of the Munich crisis. It uses suspense well, as Dobbs managed so successfully in his House of Cards trilogy. The Francis Urquhart character, so memorably played by Ian Richardson in the television series, is split between two protagonists this time, with Neville Chamberlain’s cronies, Sir Joseph Ball and Sir Horace Wilson, taking the roles of sinister plotters, appeasement’s evil fixers.
This book has pace, strong characters and fine twists in the plot, but is sadly let down by Dobbs’s dreadfully tin ear for the language and vocabulary of the 1938-40 period. Admittedly, he says in his acknowledgments that historians might get upset with his ‘meddling with the facts’, but it is not that so much as the outrageous liberties he takes with the way that people spoke in the prewar period that spoilt the book for this reviewer. For the conversations in this book are more reminiscent of Los Angeles in the Nineties than Britain in the Thirties.
When Sir Samuel Hoare spoke to the Duchess of Atholl, he would not have prefaced his remarks with ‘Christ’, any more than ‘shit’ or ‘arsehole’ and ‘fuck’ would have been used in the way that Dobbs scatters them around.
Comments
Join the debate for just £1 a month
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for £3.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just £1 a monthAlready a subscriber? Log in